Buttermilk Sweet Potato Pie

If you’re searching for a nostalgic, soul-warming dessert that’s rich, creamy, and packed with flavor, buttermilk sweet potato pie is your answer. This Southern staple combines earthy sweet potatoes with the tang of buttermilk, wrapped in a flaky crust and seasoned with warm spices that make it a year-round favorite.

Unlike traditional sweet potato pie, this variation includes buttermilk, which gives the custard-like filling a unique depth and slight tanginess. The combination of brown sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, and vanilla creates a well-balanced flavor profile that’s comforting and unforgettable. Popular during the holidays, this pie is also ideal for Sunday dinners, potlucks, or when you’re simply craving a slice of Southern charm.

You’ll find this dessert woven throughout Southern cuisine (source), where buttermilk is a cherished ingredient. The pie is also gaining traction among foodies who love fall baking ideas and comfort food desserts (source) for their nostalgic appeal and flavor-packed profiles. Whether you grew up eating this dish or you’re just discovering it, there’s no denying that buttermilk sweet potato pie offers the best of both simplicity and richness.

🕰️ The history of sweet potato pie in Southern cuisine

Sweet potato pie has deep roots in African-American culinary history, especially in the American South. Unlike pumpkin pie, which became more common in the North, sweet potato pie became the go-to dessert across Southern states due to the availability of sweet potatoes and the influence of African cooking traditions.

Historically, enslaved African Americans adapted recipes using local ingredients, and sweet potatoes offered both nutrition and versatility. Over time, as access to dairy improved, buttermilk was introduced into the pie filling, resulting in a smoother, more flavorful custard.

This dish is now a mainstay during holidays like Thanksgiving and Christmas, often passed down through generations with slight variations in spice levels or sweetness. The inclusion of custard-like texture (source) became an identifying feature, bridging traditional Southern desserts with refined baking techniques.

Unlike modern adaptations of pies that use canned ingredients, traditional sweet potato pies rely on fresh, mashed sweet potatoes. This keeps the flavor bold, earthy, and unmistakably Southern.

🥔 Key ingredients and their roles

Each ingredient in buttermilk sweet potato pie plays a critical role in texture, flavor, and structure. Here’s a breakdown of what makes each component essential:

• Sweet Potatoes: The star of the show, sweet potatoes provide a naturally sweet, creamy base. Using fresh, mashed sweet potatoes enhances the pie’s depth and nutritional value. Learn more about sweet potatoes and their health benefits.

• Buttermilk: This tangy dairy product contributes to a soft, custardy texture. It also balances the sweetness of the sugars and sweet potatoes. See how buttermilk transforms classic baked goods.

• Brown Sugar and Granulated Sugar: The combination provides rich caramel undertones and helps the filling set.

• Unsalted Butter: Adds richness and flavor while improving mouthfeel.

• Eggs: These bind the filling together and give the pie structure.

• Vanilla Extract: Enhances all the other flavors with a smooth, floral sweetness.

• Cinnamon and Nutmeg: The warming spices provide a signature autumnal aroma and flavor. Check out the history and uses of nutmeg.

• Salt: Just a pinch sharpens all the other flavors.

• Pie Crust: Whether homemade or store-bought, the crust is the essential base that holds the filling. For inspiration, check out pie crust options on Pinterest.

🍠 Choosing the right sweet potatoes

For optimal results, choose orange-fleshed varieties like Beauregard, Garnet, or Jewel. These are known for their natural sweetness and moist texture, which translates beautifully in pie recipes.

Tips for preparation:

• Bake instead of boiling to preserve flavor and nutrients.

• Let them cool before peeling to avoid burns.

• Mash thoroughly for a smooth consistency.

Avoid using canned sweet potatoes—they tend to be overly soft and waterlogged, affecting the final texture and flavor.

🥛 Why use buttermilk? Benefits and alternatives

Buttermilk is what sets this recipe apart. It adds a mild tang that cuts through the richness of the sweet potatoes and sugar, giving the pie a more complex flavor. The acidity of buttermilk also helps create a silky-smooth texture in the filling.

Why buttermilk works:

• Enhances moisture without making the filling runny

• Helps activate baking agents when used in other baked goods

• Adds complexity to the flavor profile

If you don’t have buttermilk on hand, you can substitute:

• 1 cup milk + 1 tbsp vinegar or lemon juice (let sit for 5 minutes)

• Plain yogurt thinned with milk

• Sour cream mixed with a little water

That said, authentic buttermilk sweet potato pie uses the real thing for best results.

👩‍🍳 Step-by-step recipe breakdown

Preparing the pie crust

Using a pre-made 9-inch pie crust saves time without sacrificing flavor. Place it in a pie dish and crimp the edges for a decorative touch. Optionally, blind bake the crust for 10 minutes at 350°F to prevent sogginess.

Mixing the filling

In a large mixing bowl, combine:

• 1½ cups mashed sweet potatoes

• 1 cup buttermilk

• ¾ cup brown sugar

• ¼ cup granulated sugar

• ½ cup melted unsalted butter

• 3 large eggs

• 1 tsp vanilla extract

• 1 tsp cinnamon

• ½ tsp nutmeg

• ¼ tsp salt

Use a hand mixer or whisk to beat until smooth and creamy, ensuring there are no lumps.

Baking the pie

• Pour filling into the prepared crust and smooth the top.

• Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 50–60 minutes, or until a knife inserted in the center comes out clean.

• If the crust edges start browning too quickly, cover them with foil.

• Let the pie cool completely before serving to allow it to set.

Explore more Thanksgiving pies here.

🧑‍🍳 Expert tips for the perfect pie

• Pre-bake the crust slightly to avoid sogginess.

• Use room-temperature ingredients for smoother blending.

• Avoid overmixing, which can create air bubbles and cracks.

• Cool fully before slicing—this ensures the filling sets perfectly.

• Cover the crust edges with foil if browning too quickly.

For more seasonal inspiration, check out fall baking recipes.

🥄 Variations on buttermilk sweet potato pie

• Gluten-free crust: Use a gluten-free pie crust mix or almond flour base.

• Lower sugar: Reduce sugar amounts or use maple syrup for sweetness.

• Pecan topping: Sprinkle chopped pecans on top before baking.

• Mini pies: Use muffin tins for individual servings—great for parties.

• Dairy-free version: Use plant-based butter and a dairy-free buttermilk alternative (like soy milk + vinegar).

Check out more sweet potato desserts here to find other creative ideas.

🧾 Nutritional information & serving suggestions

Serving tips:

• Serve with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream.

• Pairs well with black coffee or spiced tea.

• Add a dash of cinnamon on top for extra aroma.

❌ Common mistakes to avoid

• Using canned sweet potatoes: Too watery and less flavorful.

• Skipping the cooling time: Causes the filling to fall apart.

• Overbaking: Leads to a dry and cracked top.

• Under-seasoning: Don’t skimp on spices; they define the flavor.

• Not smoothing the top: Leads to uneven baking.

Review these comfort food desserts here for more baking tips.

❓ FAQs: People also ask

What does buttermilk do in sweet potato pie?
Buttermilk adds a subtle tanginess and helps create a creamy, custard-like texture that enhances the natural sweetness of the pie.

Can I use canned sweet potatoes instead of fresh?
While you can, it’s not recommended. Fresh sweet potatoes offer better texture and flavor, which are essential for a quality pie.

How do you know when sweet potato pie is done?
The filling should be set but slightly jiggly in the center. A knife inserted should come out mostly clean, and the crust should be golden.

How long does sweet potato pie last in the fridge?
Properly covered, it will last up to 4 days. You can also freeze it for up to 2 months.

🎉 Conclusion: Why you should try this buttermilk sweet potato pie recipe

From its creamy texture to its rich, spiced flavor, buttermilk sweet potato pie stands as a timeless classic that deserves a spot at your table. Whether you’re baking it for the holidays, a family gathering, or simply because you’re craving a slice of something soulful, this pie delivers on all fronts.

With the perfect balance of tang, sweetness, and spice, it’s a treat that warms the heart and satisfies the sweet tooth. So grab your ingredients, preheat the oven, and indulge in a dessert that embodies Southern hospitality and tradition.

Print